California's attorney general released an investigation report concluding there is no basis for criminal charges against a Mount Shasta Police Department officer who shot and killed a passenger on an Amtrak train on December 25, 2023.
The incident began when Amtrak personnel called for law enforcement to remove passenger Nicholas Detweiler, who was brandishing brass knuckles. A Mount Shasta officer boarded the train and contacted Detweiler, who appeared to be asleep. As the officer gave commands, the two engaged in a struggle in which the officer deployed a Taser and a baton. The officer then drew his handgun as Detweiler armed himself with brass knuckles.
Detweiler spun around and raised his arm to punch an Amtrak assistant conductor with the brass knuckles. The officer fired multiple rounds, striking both Detweiler and the conductor. Detweiler died of his injuries; the conductor survived.
The investigation found the evidence does not show, beyond reasonable doubt, that the officer acted without intent to defend himself and others from what he reasonably believed to be imminent death or serious bodily injury. Attorney General Rob Bonta said: "The loss of life is always tragic, and we hope that this report provides those personally affected and the greater Mount Shasta community with clarity."
Following the investigation, the attorney general's office issued six policy recommendations for the Mount Shasta Police Department, including additional training on tactical planning and de-escalation techniques, amendments to de-escalation policy, dispatcher training on communication with officers responding to armed subjects, and policy amendments requiring officers to be aware of backdrops before firing to minimize risks to bystanders.
